The biggest trap when buying a NAS isn't too few drive bays or too little memory — it'spicking the wrong CPU tier: some people pay flagship money for performance they will never use, while others chase a bargain and end up with an entry-level chip that struggles to run Docker. This article lays out the logic of choosing a NAS CPU in one pass, using 17NAS's NAS CPU performance ranking (built on real-device CoreMark scores) to help you pick by need without wasting money.
1. First, be clear: what will your NAS actually do?
No CPU tier is inherently good or bad — only suitable or not. Match yourself to one of these:
Core principle: decide the scenario first, then look at the CPU. A high ranking does not mean it suits you — a server CPU's power draw and noise can be a disaster in a home setting.
2. The four key dimensions of a CPU
1. Cores and threads
- 4 cores / 4 threads (N100, J4125, N5105): the sweet spot for everyday NAS work plus light Docker
- 4 cores / 8 threads (V1500B): hyper-threading helps noticeably with concurrent I/O and VMs
- 8-core ARM big.LITTLE (RK3588): multi-threaded throughput approaches a quad-core x86, but check the software ecosystem
2. Power draw (TDP) and cooling
A NAS runs 24/7, and every 1W of constant draw ≈ 8.76 kWh per year. At 0.6 yuan per kWh, a 10W and a 25W CPU differ by roughly 78 yuan a year — over five years, that is the price gap of an entry-level NAS. Newer platforms like the N100 (6W) and N150 (6W) have a huge efficiency advantage.
3. Integrated graphics and hardware decoding
If you want 4K in Jellyfin/Emby/Plex, what matters is not CPU compute but iGPU hardware decoding:
- Intel N100/N150: UHD graphics, AV1 decoding support — the current value champion
- J4125/N5105: H.265/HEVC hardware decoding, but no AV1
- AMD V1500B: no integrated graphics, so you basically cannot rely on it for transcoding (Synology DS923+ owners should note this carefully)
- RK3588: 8K decoding capability, though the player ecosystem depends on how well your NAS OS supports it
4. Process node and architecture generation
At equal specs, a newer process node almost always wins: the Intel 7-based Intel N100 beats the 10W N5105 and the 14nm J4125 by roughly 23%-65% at just 6W.Buy new, not old basically holds on low-power NAS platforms.
3. By tier: the CPUs worth looking at
The tier breakdown below is based on the measured CoreMark data collected by 17NAS (real-device scores for 138 CPUs, manually reviewed):
Entry tier (CoreMark < 60,000)
- J4125: the previous generation's benchmark, used in the Synology DS220+/DS920+, with a huge installed base. Still fine for pure storage, but not recommended for new builds
- J3455: an even older generation, common on the second-hand market, only worth considering on an extremely tight budget
Mainstream low-power tier (60,000 - 100,000) ⭐ the home sweet spot
- Intel N100: the de facto standard for home NAS today — 94,389 points, 6W, and AV1, working equally well in mini PCs and prebuilt NAS units. See the complete N100 NAS guide
- Intel N150: the N100's successor, a modest bump at the same power draw — preferred for new builds
- N97: a clocked-up N100 (12W), an option for mini PCs that prioritize performance
- AMD Ryzen V1500B: the chip in the Synology DS923+ — strong 4C/8T multi-threading and ECC support, but no integrated graphics
- RK3588: the ARM flagship with a built-in NPU, and the main chip for domestic Chinese NAS brands
High-performance tier (CoreMark > 150,000)
Full-power i5/i7, EPYC and similar, suited to VM-heavy All-in-One setups or business deployments. For the vast majority of home scenarios this is overkill — watch the cooling and the electricity bill.
When you are torn between options, compare them directly:N100 vs J4125, RK3588 vs N100, V1500B vs N100.
4. Prebuilt NAS vs DIY mini PC
- Prebuilt NAS (Synology/QNAP/UGREEN/Zspace): a worry-free OS and solid after-sales support, but the CPU tier is usually a notch lower at the same price. For brand-by-brand model and CPU comparisons, see the Synology, QNAP, UGREEN, Zspace brand guides
- DIY mini PC (an N100 mini PC plus fnOS/OMV/Unraid): more performance for the same money and total freedom, but you are on your own when something breaks
If your original motive for buying a NAS was replacing a cloud storage subscription, first use the subscription cost calculator to estimate what you spend on subscriptions per year and how long a NAS would take to pay for itself, then decide which tier your budget should go to.
5. Common misconceptions
- "A stronger CPU makes the NAS faster" — file transfer speed depends first on the network adapter and drives; on gigabit Ethernet, a J4125 and an N100 show no difference in SMB speed
- "A high benchmark score means everything is fine" — transcoding depends on the iGPU, concurrency on threads, and VMs on memory channels; a benchmark is only one dimension
- "ARM is power-efficient, x86 is power-hungry" — a newer x86 process node (N100 at 6W) is more efficient than older ARM platforms; look at the specific model, not the architecture label
- "Tray/ES chips are a bargain too good to pass up" — ES (engineering sample) chips carry high stability risk and are not recommended for 24/7 devices
FAQ
Q: Is an N100 good enough for a NAS?
Yes. With 4 cores/4 threads, 6W, and AV1 hardware decoding, it handles home storage, media, and a dozen or so light Docker containers comfortably. Its measured CoreMark is around 94,000 points, placing it in the upper-middle of the 138 CPUs listed. For a detailed analysis, see the complete N100 NAS guide.
Q: Should I upgrade an old J4125 NAS?
Not for pure storage use. The J4125 delivers roughly 60% of an N100's performance, so an upgrade only makes sense if your pain point is 4K transcoding or container scale.
Q: How should I read the ranking?
The ranking is based on reviewed CoreMark results from real devices; the test methodology and ranking rules are here. Note that the scores represent CPU core compute and do not include iGPU transcoding capability.
Q: Where can I verify how a given CPU really performs?
Check its measured results page directly, for example Intel N100 performance test or RK3588 performance test, which include sample details, neighboring-rank comparisons, and devices that use it. You are also welcome to submit your own score to enrich the data.
